Behavior

"But You Promised!"

Minimize the damage when you break a promise to your child

By Deborah Carpenter, Parenting
 
See Also
A parents' guide to making them - and breaking them - Parenting.com
3 ways to help your child learn a better way to ask for what she wants - Parenting.com
Things to say to halt a meltdown - Parenting.com

Kid, age 6: "Can we get ice cream after soccer?"
Mom: "Maybe. If we have time."

Two hours later, as the car cruises past Coldstone:
Kid: "Mom! What about the ice cream?"
Mom: "It's too late, honey. Your practice ran long."
Kid, wailing: "But you promised!"

Did this mom promise an ice cream stop? Of course not! But her child heard her words as a pledge. "Five-year-olds are just learning the nuances of language," says Henry Schlinger, Ph.D., director of the applied behavior analysis program at California State University, Los Angeles, "so they tend to still be quite literal."

What can you do? Begin by steering clear of wishy-washy language ("possibly," "perhaps," "we'll see"). If your kid's crushed whenever plans fall through, take it a step further and say "No playground pit stop today," even if you think it might work out. Then if it does, you'll be the queen of happy surprises.

Also, keep your head in the game. How many times have you said "Yes, fine, just hurry up or we'll be late!"? Later, when your kid's whining about a broken promise, you're racking your brain trying to figure out what she's talking about. Moral of the story: Don't make promises on autopilot.

If the request is unrealistic, save yourself the headache and simply say no. But if your kid is asking you for something that you're 100 percent sure you could grant if you tried, say yes (no matter how high the laundry pile). It's a fact of life that you'll occasionally find yourself having to break those promises, too, but if that happens, come clean quickly, apologize, and, if possible, offer an alternative or a rain check. Your kid will handle it better when it's the exception rather than the rule.



PRINT
Quick Poll

Do you loosen your rules about how many sugary treats your kids can have during the holidays?

Totally. Have at!
A little -- heck, we're indulging, too!
Nope. It's not healthy or worth the sugar meltdown.


ADVERTISEMENT
Popular on Parenting.com
Popular on Parenting.com
 
Photo Galleries

A Special Joy 2009: Kids With Down Syndrome Round 1

See photos of your snap-happy kids, who happen to have Down Syndrome, in honor of National Down Syndrome Awareness Month in October

promotion
 

Blog: Family Budget Boot Camp

Natasha: "As of today, I've paid off one card. It's a small victory, not because it was the one with the lowest balance, but because I've been in a funk. I've never been more exhausted in my life." Updated frequently.

Blog: The Parenting Post

Denene at My Brown Baby: "Kids are experts at finding the hidden, and that little flimsy lock was no match for the wits of a curious preteen and her big brother. If we wanted to see it, it was going to get seen. But this? This I wasn't ready for." Updated Daily!

The Best Toys of 2009

We're giving away over $900 worth of toys! Enter BOTH giveaways once a day until December 14
Video Games

19 Best Wii Games for Kids of 2009

Our top video game picks for the whole family