Development

Boys vs. Girls: Who's Harder to Raise

Can we finally answer the great parenting debate over which sex is more challenging to raise?

By Paula Spencer, Parenting
 
 
See Also
This mom's home and heart were filled with trains and trucks, skinned knees and SpongeBob. Was there room for a girl? - Parenting.com
Toilet-training boys and girls in their own special way - Parenting.com
What the research really says about gender and babies - Parenting.com
The real deal on how to raise a confident kid - Parenting.com
Important tips for taking care of your baby - Parenting.com
boys vs. girls - Parenting.com

Self-esteem

Who's harder? Girls

Developing a healthy self-image is critical to all kids. But as the more compliant and people-oriented gender, girls tend to grow up less confident and more insecure than boys, researchers say. Famed gender researcher and psychologist Carol Gilligan, Ph.D., calls this "the tyranny of nice and kind" -- unwittingly raising girls to be people pleasers.

"This cultural pressure to put others' needs first, ignore one's own gut feelings, and avoid asking for what one wants has traditionally harmed girls," says Jenn Berman, a California family therapist who wrote The A to Z Guide to Raising Happy, Confident Kids. "Despite the fact that she enjoys the positive attention and accolades that people pleasing brings, the more a girl pushes her own needs and desires underground to please others, the more likely her own self-esteem will suffer."

"I see a natural nurturing instinct in my daughter and her friends," says Tracy Lyn Moland, a parenting consultant in Calgary, Alberta, who has a girl, 11, and a boy, 8. "I find myself saying, 'I can take care of that -- you get yourself ready,' when she's trying to mother her brother."

Make no mistake, helpfulness and nurturing are virtues for everybody. But this tendency in girls makes it smart to help her explore and strengthen her inner nature and encourage her to try new things.

Body image is a big part of self-esteem, and though there's certainly body-image dysfunction in boys and men, it remains mostly a female issue. The natural rounding out of the body that happens in puberty clashes with the unnatural slimness girls see in the culture around them.

Be aware of the messages you convey about your own body, diet, and exercise. "It's painfully obvious that girls' negative body image can come directly from seeing their moms look critically in the mirror and complain," says Berman. "Teach your daughter to listen to her body's signals of hunger and satiety. Girls who listen to their bodies tend to listen to their instincts in other areas." Sports are a great way for girls to build confidence and a healthy appreciation for their bodies.


< PREV
page 4 of 5
NEXT >


PRINT
Quick Poll

Would you let your tween go trick or treating with just a group of friends?

No way, there are too many weirdoes out there!
For a little while, but only during daylight hours.
Sure, as long as they keep in touch with me.


ADVERTISEMENT
Popular on Parenting.com
Popular on Parenting.com
 
Photo Galleries

Mom-Approved Websites for Kids

Moms in our community recommend these sites for safe, educational, fun online games.

promotion
 

Blog: Our Editors' Daily Fave

Maura make sense of the new study that says kids should be in rear-facing car seats until age 4. Lauren reveals what it's like to interview Kate Gosselin. Plus: would you wear sperm earrings? Updated frequently by Parenting and Babytalk Editors.

Blog: The Parenting Post

Mighty Maggie: "If you thought the difference between the Greatest Generation and the Baby Boomers was huge, take a look at the expanse between the Boomers and THEIR kids." Updated daily!

Want to Test Products?

Parenting needs your opinion! Sign up for a chance to be a Mom Tester to review (and keep) toys, beauty products, baby gear and more.

Share Your Vacation Pix and Win!

Send us great family vacation photos and your best advice for traveling with a baby. Three moms will win a fab diaper bag!