Behavior

8 Discipline Mistakes Parents Make

Big discipline mistakes you might be making (and how to fix them)

By Amanda May, Parenting
 
 
See Also
How to deal with defiance - Parenting.com
Why they say one thing and then do another -- and how to know what they really want - Parenting.com
Lisa and Cliff Bolton, on CMT's World's Strictest Parents, explain why kids want to be disciplined - Parenting.com
We've got responses to 4 common kid lies that'll help them to be honest. - Parenting.com
A new study reveals kids aged 12 and up respond to discipline differently than young children. - Parenting.com
How to keep control - and your cool - while your kids test the limits every which way they can - Parenting.com
"We've recently started our 2 1/2-year-old on time-outs, but my husband gives them for everything from hitting to refusing to pick up a taoy! Shouldn't he let some things slide?" - Parenting.com
3 ways to teach your toddler remorse -- not shame -- for their not-so-angelic actions - Parenting.com
Mistakes even smart moms make, and what to do instead - Parenting.com


Share

You know the drill: You give your child an ultimatum -- "Get dressed or we're staying home!" -- and naturally she says, "Okay, we'll stay home!" Might as well plant a big "L" on your forehead. We all see our discipline efforts backfire on occasion (hey, you're tired!), and of course there are those battles just not worth fighting (no kid ever flunked preschool because his teeth were furry). But you do need to prove you're the parent at least some of the time. Learning to avoid these discipline land mines can help you hop to it.

Way to Blow It #1: Tell a Big Ole Lie

"My two-year-old daughter, Chloe, fights me about going to her babysitter's house every Monday," says New Jersey mom Gina Kane. One morning when Chloe refused to get out of the car, "I pointed to the house next door and told her it was a daycare center run by the caveman from the Geico commercials, which really scare her," says Kane. "I said she had a choice: Go to the sitter's house or to the caveman's daycare." Mission accomplished -- Chloe dashed to the sitter's door. Fast-forward a week: The babysitter casually asked Kane if she knew of a daycare center in the neighborhood because her daughter couldn't stop talking about it. "I was mortified having to explain, and Chloe now thinks that all daycare centers are run by cavemen," Kane admits. "I'm in big trouble if I ever actually have to send her to daycare."

A Better Way: Little white lies are so tempting in a pinch. You might even get away with them sometimes. Another mom had a great run while her toddler was afraid of a local clown named Macaroni. Whenever he refused to cooperate, she'd just say, "Maybe we should get Macaroni!" and the little guy would immediately don his pj's or gobble his carrots. But as Kane found out, scare tactics can and do come back to bite you in the butt, so it's best to be honest, says Bonnie Maslin, author of Picking Your Battles. Kane could have said instead, "I know sometimes you don't want to go to your babysitter. Sometimes I don't want to go to work." Empathizing would have made the Monday-morning transition easier.

Way to Blow It #2: Back Down

You want a surefire way to make sure your kids never listen to you? Threaten but don't act. My daughter Ella and I recently went for a playdate at a friend's house, where the little girl kept snatching away whatever toy Ella picked up. Her mom would say, "Give that back to Ella or I'll take it away," and then turn back to our conversation. Of course, as soon as Ella moved on to another toy, the little girl wanted that one.

A Better Way: It's no fun to be the bad guy, but if a child acts out, there has to be a consequence. "Repeatedly saying 'If you don't stop throwing sand, I'm going to make you leave the sandbox' won't stop the bad behavior," says Bridget Barnes, coauthor of Common Sense Parenting for Toddlers and Preschoolers. "What your child hears is 'I can keep doing this a few more times before Mom makes me stop.'"

Instead, give a warning, and then, if your child does it again, give an immediate consequence such as a time-out. If he continues, leave. The next time, a gentle reminder should do the trick: "Remember how we had to leave when you threw the sand? I hope we don't have to go home early again today."


1
2 3 4 NEXT >

1
2 3 4 NEXT >
PRINT

Comments

Displaying comments 1 - 2.
on Feb 08, 2010
This is a great read. As the coauthor of Common Sense illustrates it really is simple to be more effective communicating with your kids but I think we all benefit from quick reminders and slightly different perspectives like these. I found this article from a discipline focused website that has a few other child discipline related articles that parents may find helpful. http://www.disciplinetoday.com Cheers, Ben
on Mar 01, 2010
This surely works,soft and mild approaches to parenting at an early stage is the best.meanwhile discipline is also to be meted out lovingly.
Quick Poll

Is it OK for couples to fight in front of their kids?

Yes
No


ADVERTISEMENT
Popular on Parenting.com
Popular on Parenting.com
 
Photo Galleries

Giving Up the Pacifier

10 clever ways to get your child to give up the paci

promotion
 
Contests & Giveaways

Baby & Child Model Search

February's gorgeous winners -- plus, the Readers' Choice

Blog: Project Pregnancy

Jennifer Johnson: "'A few weeks ago I had a dream I was pregnant with an alien. It's on the weird side but not as strange as my friend who had a dream she birthed robotic puppies and tried to nurse them." Updated frequently!

Blog: The Parenting Post

Mighty Maggie: "My husband's on a business trip this whole week and Monday morning I set the dial on my brain to Laid Back Who Cares If You Are Wearing Pajamas And Have Peanut Butter In Your Hair At Four In The Afternoon Mom." Updated daily!

30 Brand-New Birthday Cakes

ALL NEW! Super cute and easy birthday cakes you can make from store-bought cake, frosting and candy
Health

19 Famous People with ADHD

Justin Timberlake, Will Smith and 17 other celebs with ADD or ADHD