Behavior

The No-Santa Threat

By Robert Herguth, Parenting


Share

Time was, parents threatened unruly children with a lump of coal for Christmas. Today's kids  -- who barely know what a lump of coal even looks like  -- often hear a new spin: If you don't pick up your toys (or clean your plate, or say you're sorry), "Santa won't visit us this year!"

It's an understandable tactic, but not a smart one. "Discipline should be about teaching, not threatening," says Roni Cohen Leiderman, Ph.D., a develop-mental psychologist in Fort Lauderdale, FL. Invoking the wrath of St. Nick  -- or the Easter Bunny, or any other beloved icon  -- as you scold your kid takes away from what should be a happy childhood notion.

Plus, the consequences of your child's misbehavior should be logical, says Leiderman. Denying him Christmas presents long after a misdeed teaches him nothing, not to mention that it's just plain cruel (if you can even bring yourself to do it!).

Dragging doctors or policemen into the fray is also a bad idea. After all, you want your child to build trust in authority figures, not learn to fear them  -- tempting as it may be to pretend to call the cops when he throws a king-size tantrum.

So when he misbehaves  -- say, he dumps his food on the table after you warn him not to  -- give him an immediate, related punishment, like sending him away without dessert. He'll learn what happens when he acts out, and can still enjoy no-strings-attached gifts from Santa.


PRINT

Comments

No comments yet. Log in or register below to be the first.
Quick Poll

Is it OK for couples to fight in front of their kids?

Yes
No


ADVERTISEMENT
Popular on Parenting.com
Popular on Parenting.com
 
Photo Galleries

Giving Up the Pacifier

10 clever ways to get your child to give up the paci

promotion
 
Health

Join the Fit Generation

Become a member for a chance to win one of two amazing family trips

Blog: Project Pregnancy

Jennifer Johnson: "'A few weeks ago I had a dream I was pregnant with an alien. It's on the weird side but not as strange as my friend who had a dream she birthed robotic puppies and tried to nurse them." Updated frequently!

Blog: The Parenting Post

My Brown Baby: "My girls' toys reflect the truly diverse world they live in, where the kids who fill their school rooms and playgroups speak different languages and come from different countries and backgrounds and income levels and aren't necessarily a bunch of frilly little tea-toting girls." Updated daily!

30 Brand-New Birthday Cakes

ALL NEW! Super cute and easy birthday cakes you can make from store-bought cake, frosting and candy
Health

19 Famous People with ADHD

Justin Timberlake, Will Smith and 17 other celebs with ADD or ADHD