Second child syndrome: Does number two get shafted?
March 9, 2010
Is Nora (at 7 weeks in this pic) already getting gypped?
I am the second child in my family and always felt like I got plenty of attention but now that I have my own second child I am suddenly feeling…short shrifted. How could I not have been? Not only was I the second child, I was the second girl. And I had colic! Obviously I got the hand-me-down clothes and never sat shotgun, but it’s more than that. With your first baby, motherhood is so new and exciting and scary and all encompassing. Number two is exciting, of course, but there just isn’t as much time to revel in it. Because you’re divided—your attention is divided, your patience is divided, your threshold for crap is divided (though, miraculously, not your love...that just doubles). You can’t possibly be everything to your number two because number one is still there demanding that you make him pancakes...with strawberries not bananas!
In our little family the SCS began before Nora was even born—if it weren’t for the project pregnancy blog (and the Cheetos cravings) I would barely have noticed I was pregnant. I never even got on the web to see if she was the size of a lemon or a squash or a grapefruit. With Alex, I couldn’t tear myself away from that stuff. And since her arrival 8 weeks ago today, she has continued getting quietly gypped. Here’s how:
- When speaking about Nora, it is not uncommon for me to refer to her as him/he.
- Her bath towel has “ALEX” embroidered on the back.
- She’s also using Alex’s car seat, which is red, and his Bundle Me, which is brown. On our first public outing, someone said, “Oh, what’s his name?” And how could I blame her?
- We don’t have a single photo of her in our house. Granted we have quite a few on the computer and she’s only 8 weeks old, but still. We have a photo printer in our house. We have an empty frame on display in her room. We have no excuse.
- I’m not doing baby announcements for Nora. I had planned to but I think I missed the boat and, frankly, between the blog and facebook, I really feel like I’ve covered anyone who could possibly want to know I had a baby.
- I have also not logged a single entry into her babybook, which, P.S., was bought last week. To be fair, I only put about three entries in Alex’s book. Contrary to what you might think, I am not good at documenting my children’s lives.
- Alex didn’t watch any TV until he was almost 18 months old. Nora has seen every episode of Modern Family (best show on television, btw....if you’re not already watching, hulu it now!), Grey’s Anatomy, American Idol (she’s rooting for Siobhan), and, most recently, The Hurt Locker.
In some ways I think it’s good that we’ve loosened up a bit with number two. And being that Nora is the first granddaughter in the family, I know she will do fine in the spoling department. But I don’t want to completely drop the ball here. For her sake but also for mine. She may be my second baby but she’s still amazing and I’m so happy—and lucky—to have her here. And I want to make sure I enjoy her.
Do you have two? Does your second get the shaft in any way? I can’t even imagine having three (although it does explain a lot about my sister Meghan...)
Older Post: Baby No. 2 on the Brain
Newer Post: The Good
Comments (27) Write a comment
Your Comment
All submitted comments are subject to the license terms set forth in our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use






Baby #2
Things in my family were different. I was the first born grandchild, first born child, first born daughter. I was 5 when my younger brother was born but I always felt like I was the one snubbed because my parents tried so hard to have him. My parents were looking into adoption when my mother found out she was pregnant with him. All attention suddenly shifted from me to my little brother (the ONLY BOY on my father's side) and that bred a LOT of tension, jealousy and hatred. I remember him always getting what I thought at the time was 'better things' because like you mentioned, my parents were more relaxed with him, calmer, experienced. He got a color T.V. while I still sat with my black and white, he was a boy and allowed to do things before I was because of it. My husband had similar issues being the oldest as well, he too has a younger brother who is 5 years younger than him.
So now, we have a 2 and a 1/2 year old girl (first grandchild) and a baby boy on the way due in just a couple weeks. I'm striving to make sure she doesn't feel the same way I did and not even thinking about how he might be snubbed. EVERYTHING I bought for her was pink, so naturally he is getting his own baby gear as to not confuse him with gender specific colors. ;-P He'll be the ONLY grandson, unless we have another. Financially, we are able to provide better for him, though our daughter didn't want for anything, but my husband was in the Army when she was born. I find myself wanting to send out nicer announcements than I could afford with her and wondering if SHE isn't going to be feeling like we loved him more.
I think it's all a matter of perespective. Love them equally and the rest should work itself out in the end... I hope.
baby #2
I have 2 children both girls. I really don't think the second child is getting shafted that much. I do have to get more pictures printed, we dont have a photo printer so that is a money issue. But other than that she gets new clothes and stuff just like her big sister. My husband and I feel bad if we don't do that. I was also the second child in my family but I cant recall ever feeling shafted, I don't remember much these days. I am pregnant with our 3rd child and hope to continue to try to make things equal with each child. good luck
2nd child syndrome
well let me start by saying you are not alone. I remember when I had child one we gave him our full attention and now that we have number two it is divided mainly because they are 13 months apart. I let himwatch more television more now than when he was the only child.I remember picking things out for girls or boys on the big things (swings, walkers etc). It's hard sometimes for my youngest because she is second in line and it is not as exciting because I was just pregnant. She is still special because she is a girl and I have one of each. I feel bad for her because I don't read or write in her journal like I did for my son on every milestone. When I am aware I try to make changes, and I try to do special things for my son like playdates so he feels special. I also allow him to help me with his sister. I love my kids and when my youngest is older we cando alot more.
Low expectations
I think it won't be very hard to treat my second child the same as my first baby-book-wise. I'm a scrapbooker. I have 4 scrapbooks of my own life. But I haven't even BOUGHT a scrapbook to start for my daughter (9 months). Its been on the to-do list since before she was born and it still hasn't been done. I did buy some scrapbook paper, but I sense it will never be used... At this point I'm thinking at least if I don't do a book for her, I won't have to feel guilty about not doing books for subsequent children. Besides, I enjoyed taking all the photos of me as a baby (that my mom had never done anything with) and making my OWN baby scrapbook when I was in high school. I don't want to deprive my daughter of that joy;-)
My husband is making a "first year video" for her, so the pressure is on HIM to do the same for future children!!
Baby #2
A day doesnt go by that I dont feel guilty that baby #2 is getting the short end of the stick. With my first born I had a dozen albums filled with pictures of his every waking, sleeping, eating, bathing moment. Not the case with #2. I have not even filled one album after 9 months of his life. I had a baby book for First born chronicling all his "FIRSTS".... for my second, I have the book but it sits empty.
He is LOVED and adored by my husband and I and his brother. He is not lacking for anything. But still I feel like he is getting short changed somehow. So I totally understand what you are talking about.
First of all, can we please
First of all, can we please remove the sad psycho case who keeps posting the bizarre, horrible commentary?
Secondly, I think it's so normal to shaft the second child. I was an only child for years and was used to tons of attention! When my brother was born, my parents let things roll off their back much more! In some ways he had it easier--no curfew, less pressure to do well in school, less hypochondria and in-your-faceness from my parents...But I do still like being the first born :-)
I think a big part of it also depends on whether your work full-time or stay at home or what. I always think I'd have a ton more time to focus on baby scrapbooking, etc. if I didn't have to head off to work each day and come home dead tired! But maybe I'd be dead tired no matter what.
There is no doubt that it is
There is no doubt that it is different with baby number 2 - nothing is ever new in the same way twice. I have three girls, and was the first of two girls. Here's my take: the first one gets more attention/awe even after there are other siblings. They are always the first to get to each stage, so of course it's more exciting for the parents. But with that comes the guinea pig role. Mom and dad have higher expectations, demands, and are figuring everything out with number one. Second children, or third, of fourth, for that matter, enjoy more realistic expectations, along with the many good things that come with siblings. And they know that mom and dad don't love them any less! I have yet to meet an only child that couldn't have benefited from their place in the spotlight being shared by siblings - children need to realize the world doesn't actually revolve around them sooner rather than later!!
I know this example may
I know this example may sound a bit silly, but I don't have children so I am going to have to go by the next best thing I have..my pets. Over the summer we took in a baby kitten that was left near the expressway(it runs near my house) and made its way over to our backyard...it had been meowing incessantly and we decided to take it in during a really nasty thunderstorm(he was so tiny if we left him out he would have died). We decided to keep him as we just feel in love with him. A bit after we decided to get another kitten to keep him company as he was left alone all day due to being at jobs and college all day. Anyway I can see how the 2nd one has been shafted as we didn't buy her any new toys(just shared the toys we already had) and the first one we got definitely gets showered with more loving and attention. Don't get me wrong the 2nd kitten gets plenty of loving and attention but its almost that the novelty of having a new kitten around the house that was present when we got the first one has faded since the second one came. We do absolutely love and adore them both but I certainly see what you are saying. I am sorry that this example may seem silly since kittens are nowhere near like children...but it's the only way I knew how to relate to the post.
#2
I'm currently pregnant with Baby number 2 and I can feel the attention already shifting!! While everybody is trying to remind me that I still have Number 1 (for example I shouldn't return the outfit bought for her that is too small and exchange for a neutral newborn outfit), I'm fighting to remind them that this baby needs attention too!! Only 12 weeks along and already I fell Mother instincts that I need to defend the Baby that isn't here yet from any attention that might be getting overlooked.
It's crazy! And will probably make me go insane, lol, but I know they will turn out just fine and know they are equally loved :)
What a gorgeous picture.
What a gorgeous picture. Just remember: YOU may not be able to give her quite as much attention, but Alex makes up for that by giving him a lot of his attention too! I'm the oldest in my family and I always wished I had an older sibling to lean on. So, Nora's lucky too!
Hi -- I think number 1 is
Hi -- I think number 1 is treated like royalty but he also had to live through my mistakes (simple ones... the how to stuff) nad I said I wouldn't but he is more disciplined. Babies 2 & 3 get to reap the rewards from the learning curve. I also made the mistake of allowing the older child/ren into the pictures of the younger one and just spent half of a day looking for a picture of my third child by himself as a baby. I tried to pull off a picture of his older brother (baby 1) as him but was caught by my daughter! Don't stress, Nora might get different attention but in the end I think it evens out.
Hmmm
I don't have any input really because I don't have kids, I just wanted to take a minute to say how adorable Nora is! She looks so much like you!
Winnie S
Please remove the comment posted by Winnie S IMMEDIATELY and prevent her from ever posting again.
I absolutely do NOT think
I absolutely do NOT think that second babies get shafted. The thing is, YOU may have less time for a second child, but there's the older sibling to factor in. My girls are 2 years and 11 days apart, turning 1 and 3 in under a month, and they are each others best friend! I made a point to make time to snuggle with #2, and spend some time alone with her, but she definitely has gotten less of my time than #1. And #1 has had to deal with getting less of my time too. But if you really want to look at it like someone's getting the shaft, what about #1 who doesn't have an older sibling to hang out with, learn things from, idolize? The thing is, each kid gets different things, no matter how many kids you end up with, but just because their experience is different doesn't mean that it's better/worse or any less than what the others got. So don't worry about it, and just love your babies and enjoy it!
I love reading your posts!
I love reading your posts! My son will be two next week and my daughter is one month old yesterday.
I often feel sheis getting the shaft when it comes to attention! Also all her furniture is blue or jungle animal themed. Its very nice to know I am not the only mother to feel this way. Thanks for your posts.
Also it appears you have an internent stalker... that winnie person. I hope that ends soon! Dont take her rude and crule comments to heart! Many people enjoy your blog
I had to take all the
I had to take all the pictures of Andrew down off the wall because I had gotten a professional shot of him every 3-6 months from the time he was born until he was 5. At 18 months I still only had one of Gregory which was taken two days after he was born. Rather than try and catch up I decided just to take them down. I am glad I was the first..... :)
Eh....
I honestly feel guilty sometimes because right now my (never very snuggly) son is in his "terrible 3s" (and they're getting bad) while my (VERY snuggly) daughter is just 1. I feel like all I do is correct him while she snuggles with me on the couch.
As a second child though, I don't remember feeling shafted at all. I am a little sad that I haven't had the quiet time with my daughter that my son and I had, but she LOVES her big brother and he LOVES her, so I think it'll all work out in the end.
Shafted? Certainly Not! :)
:) But of course not! Honestly, what kid ever died from not having enough baby photos (or having 3 less Baby Book entries than their older sibbling?). Watching Grey's Anatomy might be pushing it a bit too far (not like an 8 week old is watching, anyways! ;)), but common': Guilt should be out the door. Especially, as others have mentioned, due to Alex's attention, which will no doubt grow over time. I do think, though, that you should buy some more pink and purple (even though you hate pink ;)), just so you aren't squinting at a baby picture 12 years later and finding that you can't tell if it's Alex or Nora! :) HA!
Erin it was great running
Erin it was great running into you this past weekend and you were glowing from ear to ear when speaking of Nora. I don't think Nora has anything to worry about. Congrats again. I love the picture...she is SO cute! Enjoy!
shafted
I don't know we added #3 a year ago and while I try to make a point to do special things with each one, there are totally times any of the three lose out. I would say sometimes that the oldest gets shafted most simply because he is more self sufficient, but other days the baby loses out because the older two can demand attention that he can't yet.
We have pics of every stage with # 1 and not so much with the other two, but then again we have video with 3 that we dont have of 1. somewhere in the grand scheme I like to think it evens out.
Steff
I have 2 (a boy and a girl)
I have 2 (a boy and a girl) 3 yrs apart. She got the hand me downs. Bassinet, Crib, car seat, etc... But because she was a girl we splurged on her clothes. As they got older, I always made it a point to treat them equally...they both had after school activites... (hers a lil more expensive as she ice skated). When she was asleep I spent most of my time with my son and when she was up if I held her I had him on my lap so that he won't feel left out. As they got older we did mommy/daughter dates and mommy/son dates as well as hubby and I switched off of course he had the other one when I had one. It all worked out just fine and we are a super close family. I'm sure you're doing just fine. Enjoy every minute of every day with your kiddos. She is adorable.
2nd baby
our 2nd is also a girl and kinda gets the same treatment from me , but she also is more independent , and more imagination than our 1st but Anastasia gets shafted for a couple of reasons, 1) like you said the 1st is excisting and new 2nd) we now have a boy only 2 yrs younger than her. he is now 2yrs old and boys need alot of attention otherwise they might just blow the house up! :) I am a daddy and it my boy , i refer to huim as "the boy" so she never got her full limelight and he stole it but mom is good with equal rights and children but great article
We are thinking about TTC
We are thinking about TTC baby #2 sometime in 2010, so I think about this from time to time. I guess it will take a concerted effort on my part? Oh and about the birth announcement...I didn't send ours out until Jackson was 3 months old (I ordered and received them when he was weeks old...no idea what happened). But I ended up sending out two and the second had this poem:
"This announcement is a teensy bit late,
But it's only because I'm so great!
Mommy & Daddy can't take their eyes off me,
In order to mail the letters you see!
We hope our apology you will allow,
Here is a picture of how I look now!"
Feel free to steal it! :)
I can totally relate!
Yep, have two. And yes, my #2 definitely gets the short shrift, especially since her big brother has some serious special needs. But I've been trying hard to give her some quality alone time. I took her to the circus today and that was great (except for the part where she kept whining about wanting popcorn/sno-cone/one of those twirly things that lights up).
Oh, and Nora looks beautiful here and we had the same exact Ocean Wonders Aquarium bouncer, and now my sister has it. That thing works like magic and it's indestructible!
Been there, done that!
I have two sons. I am the second daughter; my husband is a second son. You'd THINK we would have paid more mind to not letting our second boy become afflicted with Second Child Syndrome, but it happens. I think it's inevitable. I wrote about the same topic on my blog:
http://www.confessionsofameanmommy.com/the-second-child-syndrome/